Sher Singh and Ors. vs. Dinesh Singh Charan and Ors [MANU/RH/1364/2017]: Rajasthan High Court
The selection of the most suitable persons is essential in order to maintain excellence and the standard of teaching in the institution
34. Article 21A has been added by
amending our Constitution with a view to facilitate the children to get proper
and good quality education. However, the quality of education would depend on
various factors but the most relevant of them is excellence of teaching staff.
In view thereof, quality of teaching staff cannot be compromised. The selection
of the most suitable persons is essential in order to maintain excellence and
the standard of teaching in the institution. It is not permissible for the
State that while controlling the education it may impinge the standard of
education. It is, in fact, for this reason that norms of admission in
institutions have to be adhered to strictly. Admissions in mid academic
sessions are not permitted to maintain the excellence of education.
59. The rule of law inhibits arbitrary
action and also makes it liable to be invalidated. Every action of the State or
its instrumentalities should not only be fair, legitimate and above-board but
should be without any affection or aversion. It should neither be suggestive of
discrimination nor even give an impression of bias, favouritism and nepotism.
Procedural fairness is an implied mandatory requirement to protect against
arbitrary action where Statute confers wide power coupled with wide discretion
on an authority. If the procedure adopted by an authority offends the
fundamental fairness or established ethos or shocks the conscience, the order
stands vitiated. The decision making process remains bad.”