Statutory Interpretation - Litigating Hand

R. Viswanathan v. Rukn-ul-Mulk Syed Abdul Wajid, [(1963) 3 SCR 22]: Supreme Court of India

When is an action and judgement in rem and personam

Roman lawyers recognised a right either as a jus in rem or a jus in personam. According to its literal meaning “jus in rem” is a right in respect of a thing, a “jus in personam” is a right against or in respect of a person. In modern legal terminology a right in rem, postulates a duty to recognise the right imposed upon all persons generally, a right in personam postulates a duty imposed upon a determinate person or class of persons. A right in rem is therefore protected against the world at large; a right in personam against determinate individuals or persons. An action to enforce a jus in personam was originally regarded as an action in personam and an action to enforce a jus in rem was regarded as an action in rem. But in course of time, actions in rem and actions in personam acquired different content. When in an action the rights and interest of the parties themselves in the subject-matter are sought to be determined, the action is in personam. The effect of such an action is therefore merely to bind the parties thereto. Where the intervention of the Court is sought for the adjudication of a right or title to property, not merely as between the parties but against all persons generally, the action is in rem. Such an action is one brought in the Admiralty Division of the High Court possessing Admiralty jurisdiction by service of process against a ship or cargo within jurisdiction. There is another sense in which an action in rem is understood A proceeding in relation to personal status is also treated as a proceeding in rem, for the judgment of the proper court within the jurisdiction of which the parties are domiciled is by comity of nations admitted to recognition by other courts. As observed by Cheshire in his “Private International Law”, Sixth Edition at page 109, “In Roman law an action in rem was one brought in order to vindicate a jus in rem, i.e., a right such as ownership available against all persons, but the only action in rem known to English law is that which lies in an Admiralty court against a particular res, namely, a ship or some other res, such as cargo, associated with the ship.” Dealing with judgments in rem and judgments in personam. Cheshire observed at page 653, “It (judgment in rem) has been defined as a judgment of a court of competent jurisdiction determining the status of a person or thing (as distinct from the particular interest in it of a party to the litigation); and such a judgment is conclusive evidence for and against all persons whether parties, privies or strangers of the matter actually decided. …… A judgment in rem settles the destiny of the res itself ‘and binds all persons claiming an interest in the property inconsistent with the judgment even though pronounced in their absence’; a judgment in personam, although it may concern a res, merely determines the rights of the litigants inter se to the res.” (at pp. 43-44)

7 thoughts on “When is an action and judgement in rem and personam”

  1. Cheers regarding the post and I find yourself being back to read a lot more! Just looking at some blogs, seems a reasonably nice system you happen to be utilizing. Im currently making use of WordPress for some my blogs but Im not happy with it up to now. Im searching to alter 1 of these more than to some platform similar to yours (BlogEngine) like a trial operate. Anything in particular youd suggest?

  2. Usually I do not learn post on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to
    check out and do so! Your writing style has been surprised me.
    Thank you, quite nice article.

  3. I am going to start a blog on the same theme soon, for this reason Im so serious about your article. Would you mind if I used a few of your thoughts for my weblog? Ill obviously point out you as the original source and set up a link pointing back to your site. Appreciate it!

  4. I think this is among the so much important information for me.
    And i’m satisfied studying your article. However want
    to statement on some normal issues, The website style is perfect, the
    articles is in reality great : D. Excellent job, cheers

  5. I think youve produced some genuinely interesting points. Not as well many people would truly think about this the way you just did. Im definitely impressed that theres so substantially about this subject thats been uncovered and you did it so nicely, with so a lot class. Very good one you, man! Seriously good things here.

Comments are closed.